Call Instant Quote Free Estimate

How to Pick a Hardwood Stain Color

The same stain looks different on every floor. Here is how to pick one you will still like in ten years.

By Andrey Kravchuk · Updated

Short answer: Test 3 or 4 stains on your own floor in your own light before you choose. Natural and medium browns hide dust and wear best. Dark stains look rich but show everything. Red oak has pink tones that show through very light colors.

Planning a project? See our hardwood floor refinishing page.

Start with your wood

Red oak has pink and orange tones. White oak is more gray and tan. Light and gray stains look cleaner on white oak. On red oak, natural and medium browns usually look best.

Light, medium or dark

  • Natural and light: bright and modern, hides dust and pet hair well
  • Medium brown: the most forgiving, hides scratches and goes with most homes
  • Dark: rich and formal, but shows dust, footprints and scratches

Test on your own floor

Ask for sample patches after sanding, in several rooms if the light is different. Look at them in the morning and the evening. A small card from a store never looks the same as stain on your boards.

Think about the rest of the house

Hold up cabinet doors, trim and a couch cushion near the samples. The floor is the biggest surface in the room, so it should work with what stays.

Finish changes color too

Oil-based finish adds an amber glow that deepens over time. Water-based finish stays clear. Ask which finish will go over your stain before you decide.

FAQ

Frequently Asked Questions

What stain color hides scratches best?

Medium browns with some grain showing hide scratches and dust best.

Can I go from dark back to light?

Usually yes with a full sand, as long as the stain did not soak in unevenly.

Is gray stain still popular?

Soft natural and warm tones are more common now. Test before you commit to any trend.