Call Instant Quote Free Estimate

Refinish or Replace Your Hardwood Floors? How to Decide

Most worn hardwood can be saved. Here is how to tell if yours can.

By Andrey Kravchuk · Updated

Short answer: Refinish if the boards are solid and the damage is on the surface: scratches, gray spots, worn paths or a dated color. Replace if boards are loose, badly water damaged, soft underfoot, or if engineered boards have no wood left to sand.

Planning a project? See our hardwood floor refinishing page.

Signs refinishing will work

  • Scratches, scuffs and dull areas
  • Gray spots where the finish wore through
  • Worn paths in hallways and kitchens
  • A stain color you no longer like
  • A few damaged boards that can be swapped out

Signs it may be time to replace

  • Boards that move, squeak a lot or feel soft
  • Large areas of cupping or buckling from water
  • Black water stains across many boards
  • Engineered floors with a very thin top layer that has already been sanded
  • You want a different kind of floor, like LVP in a kitchen

A simple test you can do

Pull a floor vent cover and look at the edge of a board. If you see a thick layer of wood above the tongue, there is room to sand. You can also drip a little water on a worn spot. If it soaks in fast and darkens the wood, the finish is gone there and the floor needs attention soon.

Why refinishing first makes sense

Refinishing keeps your real wood, takes days instead of weeks, and usually costs much less than tearing out and installing new hardwood. It also keeps less material out of the landfill.

Not sure?

We look at the boards, the subfloor and any water damage at the free estimate and tell you honestly which option makes sense. If refinishing will work, that is what we will tell you.

FAQ

Frequently Asked Questions

How long does refinishing last?

With good care, a full refinish can look good for many years. A screen and recoat every few years helps it last even longer.

Can you refinish just the damaged area?

Small repairs can be blended, but finish often looks different next to old finish. Doing the whole room or stopping at a doorway looks best.

Is refinishing messy?

Sanding makes fine dust. Work areas are closed off and cleaned before finish goes on. Ask how dust will be handled at your estimate.